Jamie Weir wins prestigious Linnean Society Medal

Jamie Weir, a PhD researcher in evolutionary biology, is the recipient of the Linnean Society’s John C. Marsden Medal for the best doctoral thesis in biology, at a UK university.

This year the Linnean Society’s Medals and Awards recognise eight outstanding individuals from the realms of science, the arts and conservation, all working to understand and protect the natural world.

The Linnean Society was founded in 1788, and is the oldest learned society devoted to the science of natural history. 

Its membership included Charles Darwin and Alfred Russel Wallace, who published their original paper on evolution in one of the Society’s journals.

This year’s medal and award recipients have all studied, conserved or communicated the value of nature in an incredible variety of ways.

The John C. Marsden Medal for 2025 has been awarded to Dr Jamie C. Weir for his thesis ‘Buffering and trophic mismatch in spring-feeding forest caterpillars’.  

Jamie Weir
Dr Jamie C. Weir - Image Credit: Daniella Di Pirro

Woodland food chains

Jamie’s work considers a fundamental question facing modern ecology: how resilient is wildlife to a warming climate?

His PhD project focused on the tree/caterpillar/bird food chain that occurs throughout temperate woodlands during spring, and is widely suspected of being vulnerable to increasing temperatures. 

The results revealed that caterpillars are surprisingly resilient and have a range of strategies that allow them to adapt to changing springtime conditions, such as the ability to feed on different trees.

This not only maximises their chances of survival but reduces the likelihood of negative impacts on other species higher in the woodland food chain that rely on them.

The findings highlight the importance of identifying which ecosystems and species have similar adaptive strategies, and which are most vulnerable to climate change and need greater protection. 

Mistiming

Climate change can affect the timing of stages in the life cycles of many different species. 

In particular, warmer spring conditions can advance many of the natural events we associate with the changing season: trees coming into leaf, plants flowering, or birds migrating.

This could potentially disrupt finely timed food chains, as some animals and plants rely on occurring at the same time as other species—such as a predator with a seasonal food source.  

The extent of these changes can vary across different species, and some are responding more strongly to the warmer conditions than others, increasing the likelihood of mistiming.  

Ambitious experiments

To investigate the sensitivity of woodland communities to climate change, Jamie focused on caterpillars, the key central link in this food chain and a vital food source for newly hatched birds.

Caterpillars must hatch at the correct time in spring—too early, and the buds from the trees they feed on will still be closed; too late and the leaves will be older, tougher and more difficult to eat. 

Bird species such as blue and great tits, which breed in spring and feed their offspring caterpillars, have to lay their eggs at the right time so they hatch when caterpillars are at their most abundant.

Jamie’s PhD project combined a re-appraisal of neglected, historical literature with an extremely ambitious set of experiments.  

Moth trapping
Jamie collecting and recording moths at night using a UV light - Image Credit: James Weir

He reared thousands of caterpillars in captivity to experimentally test the effects of hatching at the wrong time on their survival, growth, and development. 

Surprisingly, he found evidence suggesting caterpillars adopt a range of ingenious ‘buffering’ mechanisms to help them cope with the unpredictability of their spring environment. 

These strategies may also make them resilient to some of the disruptive impacts of increasing temperatures.

Hatching time and diet

These buffering strategies include ‘bet-hedging’, where there is substantial variation in the hatching time of caterpillars within a single clutch of eggs. 

This means that even if some individuals hatch at the wrong time, at least some of their siblings are likely to hatch at the correct time.  

Caterpillar species common in spring typically have a very broad diet, and can consume leaves from a wide range of different plant species, all of which open their leaves at different times.

Because different plant species are affected by higher temperatures in different ways, even if a caterpillar hatches at the wrong time relative to one species, an alternative will likely be available to feed on.

Not only that, caterpillars that hatch too early, before leaves have appeared on plants and trees, can sometimes survive for weeks without food, or burrow into leaf buds to feed on the developing tissue. 

Other ecosystems

Jamie’s work revealed that the effects of hatching late varied across different plant species, and that hatching late on some plants has surprisingly little effect on caterpillars survival or growth.

The historical focus in previous studies on oak trees as a key food plant seems to have given a misleading impression of how vulnerable these caterpillars are.

The results suggest that ecologists should re-examine other ecosystems that are also assumed to be vulnerable to mistiming, and identify how widespread similar buffering mechanisms may be.

Given the concerns about the effects of climate change, identifying which species and food chains are most threatened—and which are most resilient— is vital so that conservation efforts are directed where there is the greatest need. 

About the Linnean Society 2025 Medal and Awards

All of the Linnean medals and awards will be officially presented at the Society’s anniversary meeting on 22 May 2025.

Other 2025 awardees include a game changing botanical illustrator and an impassioned promoter and researcher of UK hedgerows and the wildlife they support.

 

"I am deeply honoured to receive the Linnean Society's John C. Marsden medal for my doctoral research. Science is a collective endeavour and many friends, colleagues, and predecessors contributed to the ideas that shaped my work - too many to name. But, in particular, I have to thank my supervisor, Ally Phillimore, for his dedicated and good-humoured mentorship. At a meeting of the Linnean Society on 1st July 1858, the idea of evolution by natural selection was loosed upon the world and a revolution in science began. It is truly humbling to be recognised by an institution with such a remarkable legacy, and that remains at the forefront of biological investigation. Not only that, it is a privilege to represent the University of Edinburgh in that long history.

The Linnean Society’s medal and award winners exemplify the very best from within our wide-ranging community, from excellent researchers and talented artists to dedicated naturalists and changemakers. This recognition celebrates not just their incredible achievements and impact on understanding, valuing and protecting the natural world, but also their personal investment in developing their skill and communicating it to a wider audience. A passion for understanding the world around us unites all members of the Linnean Society and beyond, and we applaud this year’s winners for their superb contributions and for being a constant source of inspiration for all of us!

Related Links